--- title: "The Real Cost of Bad UX in Performance Reviews" source: https://octily.com/insights/the-real-cost-of-bad-ux-in-performance-reviews/ description: "Find out what performance reviews really cost. Use our calculator to estimate the time and budget impact, and how smarter setups can save both." --- # The Real Cost of Bad UX in Performance Reviews ![Susan Smit](https://ebnnmeydktscnefergjm.supabase.co/storage/v1/render/image/public/client-logos/team/susan-smit-new.png?width=168&quality=70&resize=contain) Written by Susan Smit Publication date August 7, 2025 Categories Insights Inspiration Reading time 8 min read 8 min read 0% 8 min ## When the process gets in the way, your people and your budget feel it. Most performance review setups work just fine in the background. The workflows are connected, the data is there, and everything runs as it should. But the experience on the surface is often a different story. Pages are crowded. Too many fields are shown at once, even when they only apply in certain situations. Key sections appear all at once instead of being revealed when they’re actually needed. And on mobile, it becomes even harder to navigate. For employees, the current setup can feel clunky. For managers, it’s harder to scan and work with the information. Dashboards often feel cluttered or unclear, making it difficult to get a quick overview or focus on what really matters. Instead of supporting meaningful conversations, the whole process starts to feel like a task to tick off rather than a chance to make progress. That friction adds up. Not just in frustration, but in time, admin effort, and cost. To help you see what that really means, we’ve added a simple **Performance Review Cost Calculator** to this article. It shows how much reviews can actually cost and where smarter design can save both time and money. It’s not that the platform is broken. But when the experience isn’t clear or easy to follow, people lose interest. Employees postpone, managers get stuck, and HR spends more time chasing updates than focusing on what the reviews are meant to support. In the end, that doesn’t just slow things down. It costs time, energy, and money. The good news is that it doesn’t take a full rebuild to fix it. With better design and a structure that matches how people actually use the system, the process becomes faster, clearer, and more useful for everyone involved. And with tools like our [Octily Content Editor](https://octily.com/products/octily-content-editor/) (OCE), those changes are easy to roll out and manage. ### When the experience gets in the way Even when the process is technically sound, poor design can throw people off quickly. These are some of the issues that come up again and again: ### No clear starting point Employees aren’t always sure when a performance review is due, where to find it, or what they’re expected to do. Even inside the form, it’s not always clear what to fill in, what’s optional, or what the next steps are. ### Not built for mobile Pages often don’t adapt well to smaller screens. Text overlaps, buttons are hard to tap, and navigating between sections becomes frustrating. For employees trying to complete reviews on the go, it’s enough to give up. ### Progress is hard to track There’s often no clear indication of what’s been completed or what still needs attention. Sections can be buried or look the same, making it easy to get lost or miss something important. ### Managers get stuck Reviewing others should be quick and focused. But when the interface is cluttered or hard to scan, it’s difficult to know where to start. Managers often don’t have a clear overview of who has completed what, what’s still pending, or where to find the reviews they need to act on. Instead of supporting their team, they spend time digging through dashboards or trying to make sense of unclear layouts. That slows everything down and turns the process into just another admin task. ### HR ends up chasing Instead of using reviews to support development, HR teams often spend their time sending reminders and troubleshooting. When the experience doesn’t guide people, someone has to fill the gap, and it’s usually HR. It all adds up. Completion rates drop. Conversations are missed. Employees feel disconnected from the process, and HR loses visibility when it matters most. The longer it takes to complete a task or figure out what’s expected, the faster people lose interest. That’s when reviews stop feeling useful and start to feel like a burden. ### What performance reviews are really costing you A performance review process that’s clunky, manual, or not tailored to how your team works doesn’t just cause frustration, it costs time and money. According to research by the [Corporate Executive Board (CEB) (opens in a new tab)](https://hbr.org/2016/10/the-performance-management-revolution), managers spend an average of 210 hours per year on performance management activities, including training, filling out evaluations, and delivering feedback. [McKinsey (opens in a new tab)](https://www.mckinsey.com/capabilities/people-and-organizational-performance/our-insights/better-performance-management-drives-better-organizational-performance) research highlights that companies focusing on their people’s performance are 4.2 times more likely to outperform their peers, realizing an average of 30% higher revenue growth and experiencing attrition rates five percentage points lower. While using a pre-built review tool is a step forward from manual processes, further customizing it to fit your team’s real workflows can make a significant difference. ### What’s really taking up time? Performance reviews aren’t just about the conversation. Behind every meeting is a long list of tasks that eat into everyone’s schedule, often without adding value. **Estimated Time Spent Per Review Cycle** #### Role - Employee - Manager - HR / People Team #### Time Spent - ~3–4 hours total: completing the form, preparing, and attending the meeting. - ~2 hours writing the review and scheduling, plus 30–60 minutes for the meeting. - ~0.5–1 hour for admin tasks (issuing forms, chasing completions), plus 1–3 hours for calibration, final reviews, and system close-out depending on complexity. Multiply this across every employee, every cycle, and it becomes one of the most time-intensive processes in any organization. **What Drives the Time Cost?** #### Driver - Team Size - Review Frequency - Form Length & Rating Complexity - Tech & Automation - Culture (Coaching vs. Compliance) - Rules & Regulations #### How It Adds Time - Bigger teams mean less time per person, but more time spent on calibration discussions. - Shorter, more frequent check-ins take less time per round and help teams act while feedback is still fresh. This speeds up behavior change and leads to faster, visible impact. - Longer forms and detailed rating systems mean more writing, longer meetings, and more HR checks. - Without tools to help, HR and managers spend more time on manual tasks. - Turning feedback into a habit doesn’t just make reviews easier, it makes them more effective. The faster teams act, the faster you’ll see results. That can mean higher output, better quality, and long-term cost savings. - Public or union rules can mean more HR involvement and extra paperwork. **Can You Reduce the Time?** Yes, with the right changes. Simpler forms, better guidance, clear role expectations, and automation tools can dramatically reduce admin time and prep work. You won’t eliminate all the hours. But you can focus them where they matter: real conversations, not logistics. #### What Can Be Reduced - Admin Time (HR) - Manager Writing Time - Meeting Scheduling Time - Form Length - Calibration Overhead #### How - Automate form issuance, reminders, and close-out. - Use templates, clear rating scales, and comment suggestions. - Integrate scheduling tools or set fixed review windows. - Shorten or remove low-value questions. - Clarify rating guidance upfront to reduce back-and-forth. On average, teams that implement these changes can [reduce total review time by 30–50% (opens in a new tab)](https://www.gartner.com/en/articles/reinventing-performance-management). Ready to see what that means for your team? ### Performance review cost calculator Performance reviews aren’t just time-consuming. They’re expensive. Especially when the process isn’t streamlined. This calculator helps you estimate the true cost of your current review setup based on employee numbers, frequency, and time spent per review. It also shows how much time and budget you could save by optimizing your workflow. That could mean customizing review forms, automating steps, or removing unnecessary manual tasks. Use it to decide whether improving your process is worth the investment. ## Performance review cost calculator Number of Employees: Average Salary: ℹ️ Annual gross salary per employee, including bonuses and benefits. €$£AUD Reviews per Employee per Year: People Involved per Review: ℹ️ Includes employee, manager, HR, or others who contribute to the review process. Time Spent per Person per Review (in minutes): ℹ️ Includes prep time, form-filling, the actual review meeting, and follow-up admin. Time Saved per Person per Review (in minutes): Calculate ### What better UX looks like Good UX means the review process actually helps people get work done, instead of holding them back. These are the elements that make a difference: ### Clear calls to action Everyone should know what to do next without needing to ask. ### Logical page flow Steps should follow a natural order, especially when tasks move between people. ### Mobile-friendly layouts Reviews should work just as well on a phone as on a desktop. ### Smarter reminders Helpful nudges, not spam. Sent at the right time, with the right message. ### Custom layouts by role Because learners, managers, and admins need different views and controls. The goal isn’t to make it prettier. It’s to make it work better. Employees should know where they are, what’s expected, and how to finish. Managers should feel confident reviewing and approving. HR should see progress, not panic. ### Where Octily comes in Performance reviews work better when the experience is built around how your team actually uses the platform. That’s where smart design makes a difference. **What We Optimize** - Simplified layouts that reduce friction - Mobile-friendly setup so reviews can be done anytime - Branded styling for a consistent experience - Visual hierarchy that brings the most important steps to the surface - Prompts and helper text to guide users along the way - Only showing the fields that matter, based on role, step, or status **How It’s Delivered** - Featuring review reminders on the [Welcome Page](https://octily.com/customization/welcome-page/) - Sending timely [Browser Notifications](https://octily.com/products/browser-notifications/) - Creating focused layouts that reduce clutter and increase clarity - Applying logic to show the right content to the right person - Supporting [Custom Pages](https://octily.com/customization/custom-pages/) and [Standard Pages](https://octily.com/customization/standard-pages-processes/) #### Let’s make reviews work for you Performance reviews don’t have to be a headache. And improving them doesn’t mean starting from scratch. Small changes to layout, timing, or guidance can make a big impact, for employees, managers, and HR. A better experience means better outcomes. More clarity. Less stress. And higher completion rates. Curious what that could look like for your team? [Get in touch](https://octily.com/get-in-touch/), [send an email](mailto:octily@octily.com?subject=Let%27s%20build%20something%20amazing%20together), or [book a meeting](https://octily.com/meet). We would love to explore what we can create together. ![Susan Smit](https://ebnnmeydktscnefergjm.supabase.co/storage/v1/render/image/public/client-logos/team/susan-smit-new.png?width=168&quality=70&resize=contain) Written by Susan Smit August 7, 2025 Get notified about new articles Your browser asks for permission first. Delivery via OneSignal, details in our [Privacy Policy](https://octily.com/privacy-policy/#push-notifications). ![Octily Content Editor](https://octily.com/assets/octily-content-editor-DWKOFO7u.webp) Products ### Octily Content Editor Give HR teams the power to create, update, and manage Cornerstone pages independently with a real-time editor. Explore More [Customization ### Workforce AI (formerly Galaxy) Customize Cornerstone Workforce AI (formerly Galaxy) to match your HR strategy with AI-powered workflows and branded experiences. Explore More](https://octily.com/customization/cornerstone-galaxy/) [Customization ### Standard Pages & Processes Redesign everyday Cornerstone pages and processes to match your brand and improve usability. Explore More](https://octily.com/customization/standard-pages-processes/) [Customization ### Analytics & Reporting Unlock data-driven insights with custom dashboards and reporting tools built into your learning platform. Explore More](https://octily.com/customization/analytics-reporting/) ## Nice to meet you! Want to learn more about what we do? Let’s start a conversation. [Get in Touch](https://octily.com/get-in-touch/) [Book a Meeting](https://octily.com/meet)